Checked by PinkSlipped · Free tool
Roll it, or cash it?
The 401(k) looks like the fastest money in the house. This is what it costs to touch it — in this year's taxes, and in the year you'd have retired.
The 401(k) Check, part of Checked by PinkSlipped, compares cashing out a retirement account with leaving it invested, including taxes and future growth, updated Nov 10, 2026.
Take the 401(k) Check ↓A note before you begin
The 401(k) is the money that feels available. That's exactly why it's the hard one.
It is sitting there with your name on it, and every other number in the house has a bill attached to it. Wanting to touch it is not a failure of discipline. It's arithmetic, and the arithmetic is loud in the months when nothing is coming in.
This page won't tell you not to. Sometimes cashing out is the right call, and anyone who says otherwise has never had to make rent on a severance that ran out. What it does is put the whole price on the table — this year's taxes, the additional tax, and what the money would have become — so the decision is yours instead of the plan administrator's default. It's arithmetic, not advice. Take the number to someone licensed before you act on it.
Tool
401(k) Check
What touching the 401(k) really costs. About two minutes.
What it costs
PinkSlipped’s estimates update as you type. Empty fields count as zero. None of them is a verdict — they're the starting point for every money decision that follows.
—
after the plan's mandatory 20% federal withholding
—
once the real bill is settled at filing
—
what that same money would have been if you'd left it, at 6% a year
Where the money goes
- Comes out of the planThe gross distribution, before anything is taken out.
- —
- Federal income taxStacked on top of your other income for the year. The last dollar lands in the 10% bracket.
- —
- State income taxAt the flat rate you entered.
- —
- 10% additional taxUnder 59½ and no exception applies.
- —
- Total tax0% of what you took out.
- —
- Withheld before it reaches youThe plan must send 20% to the IRS. It's a deposit, not the bill.
- —
- Settle at filingNothing left to settle.
- —
The growth you're giving up
- Leave it, roll it — at 65The whole balance, compounding at 6% for 65 years. Nominal dollars.
- —
- Cost of the withdrawal — at 65Not what you took out. What it would have become.
- —
A rollover check paid to you arrives 20% short — — on this balance — and you have 60 days to put the full amount into an IRA or the new plan, making up the difference from other money. A direct rollover, plan to plan, skips the withholding entirely.
Estimates. 2026 federal brackets and standard deduction, a flat state rate, and annual compounding. Not tax or investment advice. Some plans don't allow partial withdrawals — ask the administrator before you plan around one.
Three things the math can't see
Three exceptions worth checking.
The age-55 exception lives in the plan, not in you. If you separated in or after the year you turned 55, this employer's plan can pay you without the 10% additional tax. Roll it into an IRA and that door closes until 59½.
An IRA opens a different door. Once the money is in an IRA, withdrawals used to pay health-insurance premiums after twelve consecutive weeks of unemployment compensation skip the 10% — a rule that applies to IRAs and not to 401(k)s.
One small emergency withdrawal a year — up to $1,000 — is free of the 10% from either account. Small, but real, and it's the first thing to check before anything larger.
By the PinkSlipped teamUpdated
